Judge requires COVID vaccines for California prison guards

Byrhonda Lyons, a writer for CalMatters, reports a federal judge imposed a COVID vaccine mandate on state prison employees in a federal ruling earlier his week issued in response to a lawsuit.

The politically powerful prison guards’ union (the California Correctional Peace Officers Association) and California Governor Gavin Newsom have resisted a COVID vaccine mandate, despite growing outbreaks.

California prison workers will join the list of state employees who must be vaccinated against COVID, a federal judge ruled yesterday, Monday, Sept. 27 — a loss for the state prison guards’ union and Newsom.

For months, the politically powerful union and the Newsom administration have resisted a COVID vaccine mandate for prison workers, despite the spread of the deadly virus behind prison walls. Those outbreaks have increased with the rise of the more contagious delta variant: From August to mid-September, the ruling noted, a “staggering” 48 outbreaks have been traced back to prison staff.

Dana Simas, press secretary for the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation responded to a request for comment from Lassen News with the following statement: “We are evaluating the court’s order at this time to determine next steps. We respectfully disagree with the finding of deliberate indifference, as the department has long embraced vaccinations against COVID-19, and we continue to encourage our staff, incarcerated population, volunteers and visitors to get vaccinated.   “Additionally, we were one of the earliest adopters of the COVID-19 vaccine, having rolled it out to vulnerable populations and staff at the end of 2020, and (we) have implemented robust response and mitigation efforts against the pandemic. We are also actively working to operationalize the recent California Department of Public Health Order and ensure all impacted staff is in compliance by Oct. 14.

“Currently, 76 percent of the incarcerated population has been fully vaccinated, with 57 percent of staff vaccinated and another 4 percent having received at least one dose. And to date approximately 99 percent of incarcerated people have been offered the vaccine.”

In response to questions from Lassen News, Nathan Ballard, a spokesperson for CCPOA, said he was authorized to issue the following statement by CCPOA President Glen Stailey.

“We’ve undertaken an aggressive, voluntary vaccination program and we still believe the voluntary approach is the best way forward,” Stailey said. “We are looking into our legal options to address this order.”

According to CalMatters, since the pandemic began, more than 50,000 California state prisoners have tested positive for COVID-19 and 240 have died. Yet to date only about 42 percent of guards and 57 percent of all prison staffers are fully vaccinated.

California currently requires unvaccinated prison workers to submit to frequent COVID tests.

State officials have tried cash incentives, behavioral science strategies, even one-on-one counseling to entice more of them to get the shots. But most resisters didn’t budge. Although more than 5,000 staff attended the one-on-one counseling sessions, a mere 262 agreed to be vaccinated. Roughly 4,300 others signed a statement of refusal.

U.S. District Judge Jon S. Tigar in Oakland concluded there was no evidence that further efforts to boost voluntary vaccination would be any more successful. A mandate, he added, ”would lower the risk of preventable death and serious medical consequences among incarcerated persons. And no one has identified any remedy that will produce anything close to the same benefit.”

The judge’s ruling extends to inmates who work outside of prisons or want in-person visits.

Prison employees can avoid the COVID vaccine mandate if they have a medical or religious exemption.

“We’ve undertaken an aggressive, voluntary vaccination program and we still believe the voluntary approach is the best way forward,” Glen Stailey, president of the California Correctional Peace Officers Association, said in a text message. “We are looking into our legal options to address this order.”

The judge said the state disregarded a substantial risk of serious harm to prisoners, violating their Eighth Amendment rights. The lawsuit on behalf of prisoners was brought by the Prison Law Office.

State data shows that more than 20,000 prison workers have contracted COVID and 39 have died from the virus since the pandemic’s onset. Staff outbreaks and exposure to COVID-19 led to about 5,500 prison staff absences, delayed inmate care and created a backlog of 13,000 health care appointments, according to the ruling.


COVID testing alone isn’t enough

A federally appointed receiver has overseen the medical care of California prisoners for years, the result of a class action lawsuit over inmate treatment. A month ago, receiver J. Clark Kelso filed a report recommending the state require COVID vaccines for prison staff, citing the spread of the delta variant.

“Frequent testing is insufficient to prevent institutional staff who are unaware that they have COVID‐19 from spreading the virus,” the receiver wrote.

In response to a question about COVID vaccine requirements, Gov. Newsom indicated in May that he didn’t plan on getting ahead of the California prison guards’ union, which donated $1.5 million to help him fend off a recall election.

“We have no further announcement to make as it relates to whether or not we’re going to mandate those vaccines,” said Newsom, adding that he was relying on the guards’ union to convince more of its own to get the shots.

In a previous story, CalMatters spoke to several correctional officers opposed to getting vaccinated.

“No. Never will,” answered a prison guard at California Rehabilitation Center in Norco.

“A lot of us have already had COVID and recovered, so we don’t see the point in getting the vaccine,” said another Norco guard, who tested positive for COVID in December 2020.

The judge who issued Monday’s ruling didn’t set a deadline for the state to comply with the ruling. Instead, the receiver and state attorneys will create a plan that sets the deadline

California would not be the first state to institute a COVID vaccine mandate for prison guards. Nevada did so earlier this month. In 30 of 35 California prisons, fewer than half of workers are COVID vaccinated. Some advocates urge the state to mandate staff shots.

About CalMatters

     CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom committed to explaining California policy and politics.